The CJEU clarifies the interplay between GDPR and ePrivacy for direct marketing: the soft opt-in made easier

Author info

In its judgement of 13 November 2025, the Inteligo Media case, the Court of Justice (hereinafter “CJEU”) has ruled on direct marketing and, specifically, on the applicability of the soft opt-in. The CJEU clarified the conditions for the soft opt-in as a basis for unsolicited direct marketing. Below, we discuss the judgement and how the Belgian Data Protection Authority‘s (hereinafter “Belgian DPA”) stance differs from this recent ruling. In Belgium, the DPA has always taken a strong stance regarding direct marketing and the possibilities of businesses to rely on the soft opt-in. The question now arises whether the Belgian DPA should review its stringent recommendation 01/2025 on direct marketing and its approach taken in previous decisions. 

The ePrivacy soft opt-in explained 

In principle, any unsolicited, electronic direct marketing communication requires prior consent (“opt-in”) from the recipient. However, Article 13(2) ePrivacy Directive provides an exception, also known as the soft opt-in. The soft opt-in allows businesses to send unsolicited direct marketing communication to their customers provided that the following conditions are met: 

  1. The electronic direct marketing communication is sent to the business’ existing customers whose electronic contact details have been obtained in the context of the sale of a product or service; 
  2. The communication relates to the promotion of the business’ own similar products and services; and 
  3. The customers have been given the possibility to opt-out at the initial collection of the contact details and are given the opportunity to freely and easily opt-out in each following communication. 

In other words, when you promote products or services similar to your own, you can send your customers direct marketing communication without needing prior consent, provided that an “unsubscribe”-button is always present. This is often facilitated through an opt-out link in the email footer of the direct marketing communication. 

The Inteligo Media decision confirms the soft opt-in as a legal basis 

A request for preliminary ruling on Articles 13(1) and 13(2) of the ePrivacy Directive was referred to the CJEU in the Inteligo Media case. The second question is relevant in the context of this blogpost. It sought clarification on the possible applicability of the conditions for lawful processing in Article 6(1) GDPR if unsolicited commercial communication is sent by e-mail in accordance with Article 13(2) ePrivacy Directive (soft opt-in exception). This second question allowed the Court of Justice to clarify the interplay between the GDPR and the ePrivacy Directive, and the conditions for businesses to rely on the soft opt-in. This blogpost will focus on this interplay and what the Inteligo Media decision means for businesses wanting to rely on the soft opt-in to send out direct marketing communications. 

The question the Court was asked specifically related to whether Article 6(1) GDPR and the requirement of a lawful basis is still applicable if the conditions for the soft opt-in in Article 13 (2) ePrivacy Directive are met. Although Article 6 GDPR provides an exhaustive list of legal bases allowing for the lawful processing of personal data, the GDPR remains a lex generalis. As the principle states, lex specialis derogat lex generali, the specific rule will always prevail over the general rule. The ePrivacy Directive provides specific conditions and imposes additional obligations on the controller with respect to processing of personal data in the electronic communications sector. This principle was already written in Article 95 of the GDPR and Recital 173 GDPR and later clarified by the EDPB in its Opinion 5/2019 on the interplay between the ePrivacy Directive and the GDPR. So this means that in the situations where the ePrivacy Directive “particularises” (i.e. provides specific conditions) the rules of the GDPR, the specific provisions of the ePrivacy Directive shall, as “lex specialis”, take precedence over the (more general) provisions of the GDPR. This longstanding principle has been reaffirmed by the CJEU. 

In conclusion, the CJEU held that the soft opt-in is in itself a legal basis for processing personal data in the context of unsolicited direct marketing communication. There is no need for an additional legal basis under Article 6 GDPR, such as consent or legitimate interest. The CJEU nevertheless highlighted the importance of the fact that the soft opt-in conditions need to be fulfilled in order to rely on the exception (i.e. contact details collected during sale of good/service, similar products marketing and opt-out in every communication). 

The Belgian DPA’s position 

In the past, the Belgian DPA seemed to follow the reasoning that, on top of the abovementioned three conditions for a lawful soft opt-in, a legal basis must also be present under Article 6 GDPR. In practice, this would mean that both the conditions of Article 13(2) ePrivacy Directive, and either consent or legitimate interest would need to be present for the collection and processing of personal data for direct marketing. 

We are still awaiting a decision from the DPA on this topic to see how the soft opt-in conditions will evolve in Belgian case law. It should be only a matter of time before the DPA follows the CJEU’s decision and reviews its stance, as well as its recommendations 01/2025. Stay tuned for an update on the Timelex blogpost page! 

Takeaway 

The Inteligo Media ruling gives businesses more room for direct marketing and allows for a more realistic approach in promoting your products and services. As long as the soft opt-in conditions are met, there is a lawful basis present for direct marketing communication to existing customers. A legal basis under Article 6 GDPR, such as consent or legitimate interest, must not be considered in such case. 

We can help your business’ marketing team with a direct marketing GDPR/ePrivacy implementation plan. Contact our specialized GDPR lawyers to ensure a lawful and practical direct marketing process.